I’ve read Blake Snyder. He says that a movie is a story told in three acts. Of course the second act is twice as long and broken into two halves, so the three act structure is really four acts. I’ve read elsewhere that three acts is right for any story, though the second act should be the longest and be broken into three acts itself, so the three act structure is really five acts. I’ve now heard Dan Wells talk, at least on YouTube, and describe a seven point outline for every successful story.
I’m not convinced how different these all are.
First up, some viewing. For those not aware of the Dan Wells seven point story structure (which he admits to stealing from the Star Trek RPG), there’s a talk in five parts on YouTube. I’m going to embed Part One, the rest should show up as suggested videos at the end. Please note, the production elements are not mine:
To provide some recap, he breaks the plots of several movies, novels, and even the short story The Tell-Tale Heart down into seven points that the story has to hit:
- Plot Turn 1
- Pinch 1
- Pinch 2
- Plot Turn 2
There’s a great symmetry to the structure, the story mirrors itself around the midpoint, framed at either end by an opposing hook and resolution. If the resolution is falling in love, the hook is two strangers. If the resolution is solving a murder, the hook is the murder happening. If the resolution is someone fulfilling their role as a hero, the hook is the person as a regular schlub. Plot Turn 1 is the conflict being introduced, Plot Turn 2 is the last piece the character needs. As Dan Wells puts it “the power is in you!”. The Pinches surround the midpoint, they apply pressure. The first may introduce a villain, the second may strip away a mentor. The midpoint is the center of the whole thing, it is the mirror, and it’s where the character moves from being reactive to being proactive.
This is great, this is awesome, and he does a fantastic job breaking down the seven points of multiple lengths and genres of stories, but where the lecture really kicks some ass and is in Part 4/5 starting around the 7 minute mark where he applies this seven point structure to each of the four main plots of The Matrix: Neo defeating the Agents, Neo becoming The One (he defeats the agents by becoming The One, but they are slightly different plots), Neo and Trinity falling in love, and Cypher betraying the crew of the ship. This is where I’m going to jump shift to where I originally know Dan Wells from: the Writing Excuses podcast.
In their October 2nd, 2011 episode, the Writing Excuses crew talked to Lou Anders about the Hollywood Formula. Give it a listen, it’s only 20 minutes long (though that’s now 70 total minutes of material I’ve assigned this post). While largely talking about the three act structure, the podcast also talks about the increased emotional impact of scenes where multiple things happen at the same time. Looking at the seven point structure, it’s taking points from more than one plot line (though one plot’s Pinch can be another’s Turn) and putting them together in a scene. The capture of Morpheus, the second pinch in one plot, happens simultaneously with the resolution of the betrayal plot. At the end of the movie, the three Neo plotlines all have resolutions nearly on top of each other. That’s why, while the lobby scene is all whizbang cool, the two actual emotional scenes in the movie are that midpoint betrayal and the big final fight with Agent Smith. They’re designed as big scenes where stuff happens.
Alright, so look, this is all awesome, but why am I talking about it?
Two reasons. First is because while this presents itself as a broader interpretation of the plotting of a novel, it’s really just another approach. If we’re going to look at the Blake Snyder Beat Sheet compared to the Dan Wells Seven Points, I can directly line them up (though I suspect others could line them differently):
- The Hook is The Opening Image
- Plot Turn 1 is the Catalyst
- Pinch 1 is the Break Into 2
- Both agree on The Midpoint
- Pinch 2 is the All is Lost moment
- Plot Turn 2 is the Break Into 3
- The Resolution is The Final Image
Where does that put the finale? Between Plot Turn 2, where the hero realizes he has what he needs to defeat the villain, and the resolution where the villain is defeated.
So it’s largely all the same structuring, whether you want to talk about three, four, or five acts, or seven points. But what got me excited about the usefulness of the seven point structure versus the Beat Sheet is the presentations of subplots. Blake Snyder does make room for a B-plot in the Beat Sheet, but the seven point system allows the writer to break down any number of subplots into their seven points, and use that all through their outline. Which is probably more useful than the Beat Sheet when it comes to novels. Let’s face it, the Beat Sheet is great, and it can inform someone writing for the page, but it’s for a specific purpose.
But I just buried the important word in that last paragraph: “outline.” In the past I’ve dabbled at being a discovery writer, which is fantastic for some but has gotten me into trouble. So as I’ve been learning to outline (really, it’s a hybrid outline/discovery system) I’ve been looking for different ways to approach an outline. The act structure was fine, but this is fantastic, because it allows each character’s arc to be broken into pieces at the same time as the main plotline of the book.
That’s my exact plan. But not yet. Instead, I’ve suggest to my wife we use it as one of our revision tools. Right now we’re too far into the first draft to stop and try to figure out structure breakdowns, but when we hit editing I hope breaking the story into five seven-point diagrams (main plot, and each character’s arc) and seeing where the points line up, it will show where the story as a whole is weak, and where individual character arcs are weak. Which, hopefully, will result in a stronger story after the second draft. In that way, this is a tool not just for the outline writer, but for the discovery writer looking towards a second draft. Make sure the major points are hit in each plot, and work in where they could hit better when revising. Stacking points from multiple plotlines increases the emotion of a scene (though certainly not every scene needs, or even should, have elements of multiple plotlines). Resolve them as closely as possible.
And keep an eye and ear out for structuring tools. You may, as I have, find one you’ve never heard of that entirely changes how you approach your process.